SIP-7: Staking Budget for LAND Owners

TLDR

What At The Sandbox, we were used to reward our LAND Owners with assets and SAND based on their involvement in the ecosystem. As the community noted, the staking amount has been reduced a lot during the past months, which deters a fraction of the community to hold their LAND and stake SAND. We are proposing to use a portion of the DAO’s budget to increase the staking amount to better reward the active community.
Why The DAO should focus on increasing SAND and LAND value and this participates in the narrative where LAND Owners are key to our ecosystem. We should reward the ones who are actively participating and staking is part of the equation.
How We are requiring a 750,000 SAND total budget that will be spread till December 31st, 2024 to add 750,000 SAND to the total SAND pool currently allocated for the staking by The Sandbox from the DAO staking treasury.
When As long as this decision is approved, the Sandbox DAO will send the total budget (750,000 SAND) to The Sandbox treasury so they can increase the loot pool starting on the first week of August
Who Remy BOMPAR - Director of LAND ecosystem at The Sandbox

SIP Details

Background/Context

LAND Owners are the cornerstone of our community, representing over 25,000 people globally and owning more than 130,000 LANDs.

In 2022, we launched an airdrop of SAND to LAND Owners based on their token allocation, specific traits, and LAND locations. Given the evolving market, we need to carefully manage the distribution of SAND and the value we place on our community.

Rather than conducting another SAND airdrop, we aim to support our active and committed LAND Owners. These key stakeholders, who contribute to the appreciation of LAND and SAND values, can participate through staking.

Staking involves locking a certain amount of cryptocurrency in a wallet to support blockchain operations, earning rewards in return, usually in the form of additional tokens. Staking has been available in The Sandbox environment since September 2022, accessible here: Enter your account - The Sandbox

With 20,000,000 SAND currently locked by 4,500 stakers, we have distributed over 8.8 million SAND to our LAND Owners so far. To further incentivize participation, we propose allocating a portion of the DAO’s budget to the LAND Owner pool and increasing the APY for the second half of the year. This will boost APY (current rate is around 5%) during this period, assuming the number of stakers remains stable.

More informations on LANDs in our Discord channel:

Description

We will allocate a portion of the DAO’s budget, specifically 750,000 SAND, to enhance the LAND Owner staking pool. This additional budget will be distributed over a set period thereby increasing the overall reward volume for LAND Owners.

The DAO will decide whether to implement this operation.

Upon approval of the SIP, the DAO will transfer the funds to The Sandbox blockchain team, who will then allocate the new budget to the staking pool.

Users can take advantage of this enhancement by staking SAND tokens in the pool dedicated to LAND Owners. As a reminder, each LAND allows its owner to stake up to 2,000 SAND.

Rationale and benefit

LAND Owners have been requesting more rewards for some time, especially as LAND prices have been dropping. We believe that providing additional value to LAND Owners presents a significant opportunity, but we want to ensure that these rewards benefit only our active members. We emphasize the importance of remaining engaged within The Sandbox community.

Only users who stake in the LAND Owner pool will be eligible for these enhanced rewards. Currently, the weekly reward pool is 15,000 SAND, which averages out to approximately 3.5 SAND per week per staker. By increasing the pool to 47,000 SAND (750,000 divided by 23 weeks), we can potentially raise the weekly rewards to 7 SAND per staker, assuming the number of active LAND Owners remains stable and the total value locked persists at this level.

We believe that this initiative will not only address the concerns of our LAND Owners but also reinforce the value of staying active and engaged within our community. By rewarding those who contribute to the ecosystem, we aim to create a more dynamic and prosperous environment for all stakeholders.

Risk analysis

Advantages:

Increased Participation:

  • Attract More Stakers: Higher rewards can attract more participants, increasing the overall stake and security of the network.
  • Greater Network Activity: More stakers can lead to higher transaction volumes and greater engagement within the network.

Market Demand:

  • Token Appreciation: Increased demand for the staking token can drive up its price as more people buy it to stake and earn higher rewards.
  • Enhanced Liquidity: Higher rewards can boost liquidity as more tokens are bought and staked, potentially leading to more trading activity.

Competitive Edge:

  • Differentiation: Offering higher rewards can differentiate the staking program from competitors, making it more attractive to potential stakers.
  • Increased Adoption: This can lead to a broader adoption of the network and its ecosystem, as higher rewards might entice users from other platforms.

Risks:

Inflationary Pressure:

  • Token Inflation: Doubling the rewards often means increasing the supply of tokens, which can lead to inflation and reduce the value of the token if demand doesn’t keep pace.

Market Volatility:

  • Price Swings: An increase in staking rewards can lead to significant market volatility as speculators buy in for short-term gains, leading to potential price swings when they exit.
  • Dumping Risk: Once the rewards are distributed, there is a risk that stakers might sell off their earned rewards, leading to a sudden drop in token price.

Considerations for Mitigation:

  • Gradual Increases: Implementing reward increases gradually can help mitigate inflationary pressures and market shocks (as per a weekly staking reward).
  • Transparent Communication: Clearly communicating the reasons for and the structure of reward increases can help maintain community trust and support.
  • Dynamic Adjustments: Building in mechanisms to adjust rewards based on network conditions and participation can help maintain balance and sustainability.

Implementation Plan

Launching officially between July 22nd to 25th would be best, because it matches perfectly with the blockchain operations conducting the rewards for the next 4 weeks. If we miss this spot, we will have to wait 4 more weeks.

Resources required

Over the 23 weeks, we will allocate 750,000 SAND/23 per week, so the DAO can send the full amount so the blockchain team can set up the staking pool properly without creating delays.
The SAND will be deployed on Polygon as per the usual staking program. We won’t create a new pool of stacking, it will directly be added to the existing LAND Owner reward pool.

Metrics for Success

  • We can measure the number of stakers, staked volume during the period of activation, we can also track LAND and SAND prices and also claim rate of staked funds

Voting Options

  • Voting Options: Yes, No, Abstain
  • Voting Period: 14 days

APPENDIX

Contact Information

remy.bompar@sandbox.game
@Bellbyche on Twitter

Alternatives Considered

We also thought about airdropping / opening a claim to the LAND Owners, but we felt that it wouldn’t target the really active people and we also wanted to increase the rewards to stakers who are here for the long run.

2 Likes

I’d like to better understand why LAND owners still require to stake SAND on top of their land.

Would it be better if rewards are given to land owners just staking land itself.

1 Like

Additionally, is the staking going towards liquidity? That would make sense, otherwise yeah just give it to LAND owners on snapshots

I am supporting this initiative being in the past a stacker that was desappointed by the very low rate proposed since beginning of the year.

Hey !

I believe Sandbox wants to make sure they incentivize SAND and LAND holders in the process so it doesn’t only affect LAND retention but also SAND liquidity.
Otherwise it would create a SAND sink that would never serve the global interests.

1 Like

Thanks, I also think we should get a higher staking reward pool as compared to other projects we are devaluing our retention potential

Did not consider that, thanks for the enlightenment!

I think so too! we need more sand reward for staking!!

1 Like

I’m very much in favor of this agenda. Sandbox’s staking revenue is one-tenth that of other Web3 projects. This will make the investment extremely less attractive, which will be the reason for the price of the SAND coin to fall.

1 Like

Hey Sandfam,

I think this plan to boost rewards for LAND Owners is a great idea, but I have a couple of thoughts:

  1. Snapshot Inclusion: Some LAND Owners can’t stake their LAND right now. To be fair, we should do a snapshot to include them in the rewards program. This way, no one gets left out just because of not staking and/or technical issues.

  2. Rewarding Active Contributors: I also believe those who have created experiences and are active should get more rewards. They’re adding real value to the Sandbox Metaverse, unlike those who just hold LAND. Rewarding these active contributors will motivate more quality participation.

By making these tweaks, we can ensure the rewards system is fair and truly benefits those who are actively helping the community grow, whether by simply holding or actively participating in the growth.

If you’ve got better ideas, feel free to chime in.

4 Likes

I really like #2, that’s a good addition. Can you explain what you meant by #1 more? Staking LAND?

Not sure about what you mean by #1 as you do not need to stake a land but only to have one in polygon to be able to stake sand.

About #2 I would disagree with you on that part as I am from the opinion that incentive for stakers/land owner should be decorelated from the own from builder. Like I do not ask land owner to get some reward on the creators challenges and other asset promoting creation why would creators get something on top of other stakers? Staking is primaly a tool to bring stability to the sand economy.

2 Likes

I am a Believer in Web3 tech but particularly in this Project because I am a Creator. That said I want to support and participate in all aspects of this project owning land, creating, consuming the content, participating in contests, commenting in forums, voting in the DAO and staking Land. It says I can’t participate in my region in Land staking. The reason is not clear from the Terms and Conditions. I am from the US. I also noticed that there are no bootcamps in the US. Can I stake my land to support the Project? I will be creating experiences but have a lot to learn and need to upgrade my computer system. Are there any roles that a person from this country could fill that might help market the project in this country? The Bootcamps are a great idea I think and even kids in elementary schools could benefit if Roblox and Minecraft are any indication.

definitely agree with you on the second point, Creators are already rewarded enough with all the activations (cc. Builders Challenge and all the contest TSB already run).

Here it’s about LAND holders, both from an investment and creator point of view.

The US geoblocking feature has been released following SEC’s allegations toward SAND few months ago to make sure TSB complies with American law. Unfortunately, as long as the USA haven’t released a different statement, TSB cannot reopen staking in the country.

FYI the US are not the only geoblocked areas.

Not agree with you about #2 , creator get rewards for contest not just because they are creators.
If creators get rewards for the (quality) assets they have in workspace , and for those whose are minted it could stimulate creation and involvement.
Get more rewards for owning a Land (or more) just because we own a Land doesn’t create more creative activity imo , it will just create more speculative activity.

And to be honest , spend the DAO treasury so quickly it’s a problem for me.
I confident in a way because this SIP IS made by someone who have a understanding of the whole ecosystem but i’m not convinced.
I want more rewards on Land staking like everyone else but use the treasury DAO for that , not sure it’s the good way. Idk, I maybe wrong.
I need to read more opinions.

  • Pros:
    • Seems to incentivize the right thing (loyalty & activity)
    • Has the potential to increase 4.5K stakers to 25K
    • Targets the most invested members of SandFam
    • Doubling of SAND per week from 3.5 to 7 is very enticing and if successful could be a foundation for more SIPs
  • Cons:
    • Only targets Landowners (25K)
    • 750K is 83% of the Staking Budget category
    • Landowners (25K) only represents 0.4% of the 5.8M wallets in Sandbox
  • Question:
    • What does a “Neutral” Council Recommendation mean?

Hi @Lanzer A “Neutral” Council Recommendation means that the council does not lean strongly towards either a positive or negative recommandation on the matter.
With 5 council members, a “positive” recommendation typically means that the majority of the members (i.e., at least 3) have expressed a “positive” feedback.

2 Likes

We need to be clear that all contribute to the ecosystem, whether it is gamers, creators, or landholders…etc. If this proposal is about for land owners, stick to it. Gamers or creators already has their lucrative rewards.