SIP: Enhancing Player Participation and Ecosystem Engagement

Summary

The Sandbox ecosystem thrives on active player participation and creator engagement. However, current participation mechanisms, such as off-platform voting tools (e.g., Snapshot), may present barriers to involvement. This Sandbox Innovation Proposal (SIP) outlines a multi-faceted strategy to streamline participation, increase accessibility, and incentivize engagement by integrating voting and reward systems directly into The Sandbox game environment. Key features include in-game voting, concise SIP summaries, and small in-game rewards to foster a community-driven dynamic.

Problem Statement

Player participation in Sandbox governance and innovation processes remains a central challenge. Existing tools like Snapshot, while functional, require users to navigate external platforms, potentially discouraging involvement. Additionally, the diversity of The Sandbox player base—spanning varied backgrounds, experiences, and levels of trust—complicates efforts to boost engagement. For instance, while vote delegation could enhance participation for some, others may perceive it as a loss of agency or a risk of misrepresentation. To address these issues, participation mechanisms must be simplified, integrated, and incentivized within the gaming environment where users are already active.

Proposed Solution

To overcome these hurdles and enhance The Sandbox ecosystem, we propose the development of a specialized voting engine tailored for sandbox-style games, embedded directly within The Sandbox platform. This solution leverages the immersive nature of the gaming environment to meet players where they are most engaged. The key components of this proposal are as follows:

  1. In-Game Voting System
  • Implement quick polls and voting options directly within The Sandbox game interface.

  • Enable players to review and vote on SIPs without leaving the gaming environment, eliminating the need for external tools like Snapshot.

  1. SIP Accessibility Enhancements
  • Introduce a feature inspired by X (Twitter), where each SIP is accompanied by a concise title and summary accessible via an in-game button.

  • Allow players to read summaries and, if interested, proceed to a voting interface, increasing exposure to SIPs and reducing participation friction.

  1. Engagement Rewards
  • Offer small in-game rewards, such as a DAO badge or other digital collectibles, to players who vote or participate in SIP discussions.

  • These incentives recognize player loyalty and commitment, fostering a stronger sense of community ownership.

  1. Vote Delegation Consideration
  • Explore mechanisms to encourage vote delegation as an optional feature for players who prefer a more passive role.

  • Acknowledge the diversity of player perspectives by ensuring delegation is transparent, optional, and supported by clear communication to build trust.

Rationale

Integrating voting and engagement tools into The Sandbox aligns with the platform’s ethos of community-driven innovation. By embedding these features in-game, we:

  • Simplify Participation: Remove external barriers, making it easier for players to engage with SIPs.

  • Increase Visibility: Expose proposals to a broader audience already active in the ecosystem.

  • Enhance Retention: Reward participation with tangible in-game benefits, strengthening player loyalty.

  • Adapt to Diversity: Offer flexible options like delegation to accommodate varying levels of trust and involvement.

The success of similar features on platforms like X (Twitter)—where concise content summaries and intuitive icons boost user interaction—suggests that this approach could significantly elevate participation rates within The Sandbox.

Implementation Considerations

  • Technical Development: Create a lightweight, user-friendly voting engine integrated into The Sandbox’s existing infrastructure.

  • User Experience: Ensure SIP summaries are clear, concise, and engaging to maximize interest.

  • Reward System: Design a scalable reward framework (e.g., DAO badges) that aligns with The Sandbox’s economy and avoids inflation of in-game assets.

  • Testing Phase: Pilot the voting engine with a small group of players and creators to refine functionality and gather feedback.

Expected Outcomes

  • Increased player participation in governance and SIP processes.

  • Greater visibility and engagement for creators’ proposals within The Sandbox ecosystem.

  • A more cohesive and motivated community, driven by accessible tools and meaningful rewards.

Conclusion

This SIP proposes a shift toward a game-integrated, player-centric approach to participation in The Sandbox. By leveraging in-game voting, SIP summaries, and engagement rewards, we can simplify involvement, bridge diverse player perspectives, and strengthen the ecosystem. We invite feedback from the community and stakeholders to refine this proposal and explore its potential to transform how players and creators collaborate within The Sandbox.

2 Likes

What a great SIP Idea!

Check this out, @Delegates, @Lanzer, @batmann, @AndyRichy, and others…

Tag some folks who can contribute to this conversation – Let’s explore this idea as a community and see what comes out on the other side!

1 Like

in-game button

in-game rewards

embedding these features in-game,

in-game benefits

in-game assets

in-game voting

Most definitely, @hishmad . I 100% support this. I think it’ll directly target our player retention problems.

Hishmad are you the SIP author? Just curious is all, I thought delegates were not able to submit SIPs.

2 Likes

Yes, I authored this SIP.
In case if delegates were not able to submit SIPs, would you be open to replacing me as the designated author?

1 Like

Yes, I would be honored to carry this on, thank you for thinking of me. Do you already have a developer in mind?

2 Likes

I don’t think the existing GM and GC allows for features that are realtime and or persistent atm.

If we’re talking about implementing this in the Dev’s roadmap, tbh I’m not too keen to have this added to their plate atm.

While I am all for generating more buzz for the DAO, the hype will fizzle out after awhile.

DCL has attempted this and from what I see, they’ve reverted back to webpage for both discussions as well as voting.

Perhaps a lighter touch would be to have a DAO Hall that educates people on the structures and workings of the DAO, and then lead them here for further engagement.

4 Likes

I’d appreciate it if you could explain the process for transferring SIP authorship to you.

1 Like

Hishmad is proposing a “SIP Idea” here.

He just went ahead and put into a SIP format.

This is a conversation we should all have more publicly: how far can a delegate advance an idea before others might pick it up as an author?

In this instance, this ISP Idea can be picked up by anyone who wants to co/author it.

2 Likes

Point of clarity: Hishmad proposed a “SIP Idea”

2 Likes

As of right now, there is no process other than public and acknowledgement by both parties (the one/s who advanced the idea + the one/s who want to author the SIP formally). CC: @Lanzer

2 Likes

Yeah agreed, I see nothing wrong with what hishmad did. The only topic of discussion is acknowledging that when a delegate proposes a DIP idea, their yes vote is probably automatic. As long as we acknowledge as a group that there’s no conflict of interest with that, then we should be fine.

2 Likes

Intern, when you say DCL already attempted this, can you point me to where that is? I don’t think I’m familiar with DCL.

1 Like

We can publicly transfer it here and now. Did you have more details to share, or is your original post the extent of what you developed?

2 Likes

That’s all I have. I appreciate you asking.

2 Likes

Okay thanks. I invite you to stay as involved as you can. I’ll be the official author from now on. There’s a lot about this I don’t understand so I’ll be learning as we go. And if this SIP Idea gets invited to write the SIP, I’ll need to know enough to write it without you.

For #2 in your original post, did you imagine a voting integration with Snapshot on X?

2 Likes

Note 2 points here for context.

  1. That the author HPrivakos is a long time (now ex)DCL Foundation dev who dedicated his own personal time to this. Controversial guy but nonetheless proficient in dev work. 1k seems like a nominal sum that he was asking for.

  2. Unlike TSB, DCL is open sourced and so anyone can implement anything, even fork the client(which has happened, DCL has a 2D client). To my knowledge, software differences are quite distinct as well in comparison.

3 Likes

Ohhhhhh. DCL = Decentraland. Got it.

I think I’m lost on the point you are making, Intern. My fault, not yours. I’m having trouble connecting the dots.

2 Likes

While API integration with Snapshot, mirroring The Sandbox DAO Proposals, is feasible, I suggest exploring the development of a voting engine by the Sandbox team for broader community use.

3 Likes

No probs.

My point is, I’m all for bringing more awareness about the DAO to the wider TSB community, but not in the form of implementing an in world voting mechanism PRIMARILY because it adds more work on TSB dev team’s plate.

As you may have already noticed time again, every creator in TSB that is also here in the DAO, is of the opinion that there’s much work to be done on refining/improving GC and GM. Adding such functions will only slow down an already slow moving train.

My suggestion, pivot to an awareness campaign that involves an in world experience.

4 Likes

So your main proposal is to enable an in-game SIP voting mechanic, yes?

1 Like